Unapproved overtime is time an employee worked beyond the regular workday without anyone asking for it or approving it in advance. At month end it shows up in the report, and the question comes up: do you have to pay for it?
This guide is for employers, office managers and payroll clerks in Israel: what the law says, what changes when you knew the employee was staying, and how to set simple rules that prevent the dispute in advance.
The short answer
Section 16 of Israel's Hours of Work and Rest Law sets overtime pay at no less than 125% for the first two overtime hours each day, and no less than 150% from the third hour. The section does not make payment conditional on prior approval.
What decides it is whether the employee worked. Section 1 of the law defines working hours as "the time during which the employee is at the disposal of the work". So the question is not whether a manager signed, but whether the employee worked for you in those hours.
In practice, when there is a dispute, the facts are checked:
- Did you know? You saw the employee staying, or the hours appeared in the attendance report.
- Did you receive the work? The tasks finished in those hours reached you and were used.
- Did you tell them not to work? There was a clear instruction, given in advance, not to stay without approval.
If there is a dispute, the Labor Court decides according to the circumstances of each case.
When the employer knew
Most disputes about unapproved overtime don't start with an employee hiding in the office at night. They start with a familiar situation:
Example: In the week of the month-end close, the office bookkeeper stays every evening until 19:00. The manager sees the light on as he leaves, and finds the reports ready in the morning. Nobody asked her to stay, and nobody told her to go home.
In that situation it is hard to argue she was not at the disposal of the work. The employer knew, received the work and benefited from it.
There is another reason it is hard to say "I didn't know". Under section 25 of the law, the employer must keep a record of working hours and overtime. If the attendance report shows she left at 19:00 three weeks in a row, the information was with you all along.
The opposite situation is worse. When there is no record at all and the employee sues, under section 26B of the Wage Protection Law it is the employer who must prove the employee did not work those hours, for up to 15 overtime hours a week or up to 60 overtime hours a month.
The conclusion: if overtime happens at your company without your planning it, the answer is not to ignore it. The answer is clear rules in advance, and a record that shows in real time what is happening.
A written procedure
An overtime procedure is one page, not a booklet. It tells employees in advance what is allowed, and saves uncomfortable conversations at month end. What to include:
- Who approves. The direct manager, or a specific manager for each team.
- How to ask. In advance, and in one way everyone knows: a message or email to the manager, before staying.
- What to do when there's no time to ask. For example, a customer problem at the end of the day: the employee finishes, and reports to the manager the same day or the next morning.
- How much is allowed. A weekly or monthly cap, within the limits of the general permit for employing people overtime: up to 12 working hours a day, and up to 16 overtime hours a week.
- That every hour is recorded. Even an hour that wasn't approved in advance. The employee clocks out when they actually leave.
Give the procedure to every employee, and to a new employee on day one, together with the notice of employment terms, which states how many hours they work. That way everyone knows what was agreed and what counts as an exception.
Remember: an approval procedure is a management tool. It prevents overtime you didn't plan, and shows the rules were clear in advance. It does not erase an hour the employee already worked, so it works only together with accurate recording.
Recording and approval
The procedure works only if you see the hours in real time, not at month end. Three simple habits:
- Record the real hours. Clock-in and clock-out as they were, not as planned. Section 25 requires a record of the hours the employee actually worked. "Fixing" the report to the planned hours doesn't cancel the hours. It only deletes the record that was supposed to protect you.
- The manager goes over the report every week. Who accumulated overtime, and which hours weren't approved in advance. A week later the employee still remembers why they stayed, and there is still something you can change this month.
- Talk right away. Unapproved overtime is a signal: maybe there is a heavy workload, maybe a task ran long, maybe the employee doesn't know the procedure. A short conversation that same week is better than an argument over an amount on the payslip.
Before closing the month, check that overtime appears separately from regular hours, and that it goes to payroll at the right rate.
When it keeps happening
One employee staying once a month is not a problem. An employee who stays almost every day, even though you asked them not to, needs handling.
- Understand why. Too many tasks? A deadline that doesn't fit the hours? Habit? Or do they want the extra on the payslip? Each reason has a different solution.
- Adjust the work. If the load is real, divide the tasks differently, move a deadline, or approve overtime in advance for a defined period.
- Give a clear written instruction. "From today, overtime only with my prior approval", with a date. And keep it.
- Check every week. After the instruction, go over the employee's report each week, and talk to them right away when there is an exception.
There is also a legal side: the general permit limits the workday to 12 hours and overtime to 16 hours a week, and the responsibility to stay within the limits is the employer's. An employee who repeatedly stays without approval can put you over the permit.
If the employee keeps going against a clear instruction, it becomes a disciplinary question. Before any such step, consult an employment lawyer.
How this looks in ProperTime
ProperTime is an attendance system where overtime is visible during the month, not only after the payslip has gone out:
- Recording from anywhere. Employees clock in from the mobile app, the computer or a physical time clock, and all clock-ins go into the same system. Both an employee who stays in the office after everyone else, and one who closes a task from home.
- Overtime shown separately. The hours report shows overtime separately from regular hours, so you can see who is already accumulating overtime.
- Manager approval. Managers approve reports and review exceptions through the month, and receive daily reports and alerts.
- Payroll file. At month end the approved hours go out in a file ready to load into leading payroll systems, with the overtime rates.
That way every overtime hour passes through a manager before it reaches the payslip, and the conversation with the employee happens that week, not a month later.
This is general information on Israeli law, correct as of October 2026. How a dispute about overtime is decided depends on the details of each case. A collective agreement, an extension order for your industry or the employment contract may give the employee better terms, and some employees are not covered by the law. For your own case, check the source or consult an employment lawyer.
Sources (checked October 2026): the Hours of Work and Rest Law, sections 1, 16 and 25, and the Wage Protection Law, section 26B (Hours of Work and Rest Law, Wage Protection Law, both in Hebrew); the general permit for employing people overtime (Israel's Reshumot 7732, 19 March 2018).
Want to see every overtime hour before it reaches the payslip? Leave your details and we'll set up a 14-day trial for you, with human support all the way. No commitment, no credit card.